Frontend School

Navigating Underperformance: Giving Difficult Feedback to a Peer

Theory
medium

Navigating Underperformance: Giving Difficult Feedback to a Peer

Medium
Behavioral
Feedback
Communication
Leadership
Interpersonal Skills

Overview

In a fast-paced environment like Uber, timely and constructive feedback is crucial for individual growth and team success. Sometimes, this feedback can be difficult to deliver, especially when it addresses performance gaps or behavioral issues. This problem challenges you to articulate a structured and empathetic approach to such a scenario, demonstrating your ability to foster a high-performing team.

What you need to do / Task

Describe, in detail, the specific steps you would take to approach giving difficult feedback to a peer. Your answer should cover your actions before, during, and after the conversation, outlining your strategy for preparation, delivery, and follow-up.

The question

Imagine you are an L4 engineer on a critical Uber platform team. You've noticed that a relatively new L3 engineer on your team, Alex, has been consistently delivering code that requires significant rework during code reviews, frequently missing agreed-upon sprint deadlines, and sometimes becomes defensive when their work is critiqued. This has started to impact team velocity and morale, and you're concerned about Alex's growth and the team's overall performance.

How would you approach giving Alex difficult feedback regarding these observations? Detail your strategy and specific actions for:

  1. Preparation: What would you do before the conversation?
  2. The Conversation: How would you structure and conduct the feedback discussion itself?
  3. Follow-up: What actions would you take after the initial conversation?

What a strong answer covers

  • Thorough Preparation: Demonstrates gathering specific, objective data and defining clear objectives for the feedback session.
  • Constructive Delivery: Articulates a clear, empathetic, and actionable strategy for the conversation, potentially using frameworks like SBI (Situation-Behavior-Impact).
  • Managing Reactions: Shows awareness of potential emotional responses and how to navigate them effectively.
  • Solution-Oriented Follow-up: Includes a plan for support, setting clear expectations, and monitoring progress to ensure positive change.

Examples

1

Example 1

Input:

How would you give difficult feedback to an underperforming peer?

Output:

My approach would involve:

  • Preparation: Gather specific, objective examples of missed deadlines and code review comments. Identify the impact on the team and Alex's growth. Determine desired outcomes (e.g., improved code quality, meeting deadlines).
  • Conversation: Schedule a private meeting. Start by stating positive observations. Use the SBI (Situation-Behavior-Impact) framework to deliver feedback. Focus on observable behaviors and their impact. Listen actively to Alex's perspective and collaboratively identify solutions. Offer support.
  • Follow-up: Agree on concrete action items and schedule a follow-up check-in. Offer continued mentorship or resources as needed. Monitor progress and provide positive reinforcement.

Constraints

Constraints & assumptions

  • Assume you are collaborating closely with Alex on projects, and you have observed these patterns directly over several weeks.
  • You value team collaboration, individual growth, and maintaining a positive working relationship.
  • This is your first time formally addressing this specific issue with Alex.
  • You are acting as a peer, not their direct manager.

Out of scope

  • Escalating to Alex's manager before attempting to provide direct feedback.
  • Providing specific code examples or debugging Alex's code; focus on the feedback process itself.

What interviewers evaluate

  • Structured Approach: The clarity and logical flow of your plan (before, during, after).
  • Empathy and Impact Awareness: Your consideration for Alex's perspective and the broader team's health.
  • Proactive Problem-Solving: Your ability to offer solutions and support, not just identify problems.
  • Articulated Actionability: The concreteness and practicality of your proposed steps.

Loading editor...