Frontend School

Lexicographically Smallest Valid Parenthesization with Limited Empty Wildcards

DSA
hard

Lexicographically Smallest Valid Parenthesization with Limited Empty Wildcards

Hard
Backtracking
String

Overview

In language parsing and compiler design, correctly balancing parentheses is fundamental. This problem extends the classic valid parenthesization challenge by introducing wildcards and a constraint on their usage. The goal is to find the lexicographically smallest interpretation of a flexible string that maintains valid parenthetical structure, reflecting a common need to find an optimal (e.g., canonical) representation under ambiguity.

What you need to do / Task

Implement a function findSmallestValidParenthesization that takes a string s and an integer k. The string s consists of three characters: '(', ')', and '' (a wildcard). A '' character can be replaced by '(', ')', or an empty string. However, a crucial constraint is that no more than k wildcard characters can be replaced by an empty string across the entire string.

Your function must return the lexicographically smallest string that forms a valid parenthesization by replacing all '*' characters according to the rules. If no such valid parenthesization can be formed, return an empty string.

A string is considered a valid parenthesization if:

  1. Every left parenthesis '(' has a corresponding right parenthesis ')'.
  2. Every right parenthesis ')' has a corresponding left parenthesis '('.
  3. Left parentheses '(' must appear before their corresponding right parentheses ')'.
  4. For any prefix of the string, the number of left parentheses must be greater than or equal to the number of right parentheses.

Input & output

  • s: A string containing only '(', ')', and '*' characters.
  • k: An integer representing the maximum number of '*' characters that can be replaced by an empty string.
  • Returns: A string representing the lexicographically smallest valid parenthesization, or an empty string "" if no such valid parenthesization exists.

Clarifications

  • An empty input string s should result in an empty output string "" if k >= 0 (as an empty string is a valid parenthesization).
  • If k = 0, no '*' characters can be treated as an empty string; they must be replaced by either '(' or ')'.
  • Lexicographical comparison means standard dictionary order: "()" is smaller than "(())", and "(())" is smaller than "()()".

Examples

1

Example 1

Input:

s = "(*)", k = 1

Output:

"()"

Note:

For s = "(*)" and k = 1:

  • If * is (: "(()" (invalid).
  • If * is ): "()" (valid, uses 0 empty wildcards).
  • If * is empty: "()" (valid, uses 1 empty wildcard). Both valid options are "()". Since it's the only valid choice, it's also the lexicographically smallest.
2

Example 2

Input:

s = "()***", k = 1

Output:

"()()"

Note:

For s = "()***" and k = 1: Many combinations are possible. We can use at most one * as an empty string.

  • "()(())": All * are replaced by ( or ). Uses 0 empty wildcards.
  • "()()": s[2] as (, s[3] as ), s[4] as empty. Uses 1 empty wildcard. This is valid. Comparing "()(())" and "()()", "()()" is lexicographically smaller.
3

Example 3

Input:

s = "(*))", k = 0

Output:

"(())"

Note:

For s = "(*))" and k = 0, no * can be empty.

  • If * is (: "(())" (valid).
  • If * is ): "())" (invalid, openCount becomes negative). Therefore, "(())" is the only valid and thus lexicographically smallest option.
4

Example 4

Input:

s = "(((", k = 1

Output:

""

Note:

No matter how k=1 is used, three opening parentheses cannot be balanced with no closing parentheses available.

Constraints

Constraints & assumptions

  • 1 <= s.length <= 50
  • 0 <= k <= s.length
  • s consists only of characters '(', ')', and '*'.

What interviewers evaluate

  • Correctness of Backtracking Logic: Ability to correctly explore all valid interpretations of '*' while maintaining parenthetical balance and the k constraint.
  • Lexicographical Smallest: Implementation correctly prioritizes options to find the lexicographically smallest result, including proper ordering of choices for '*'.
  • Pruning Strategies: Effective use of pruning to reduce the search space, such as early exit based on invalid parenthetical balance or if the current path already exceeds the minResult lexicographically.
  • Edge Case Handling: Correctly handles cases like empty input, k=0, and scenarios where no valid parenthesization is possible.
  • Time and Space Complexity: Understanding and discussion of the algorithmic complexity and how pruning affects it.

Loading editor...